Fix this: mitten contest pt 3

Entries into the mitten contest continue to trickle in, see parts one and two as needed. As I’d mentioned in part one, I’d based the mittens I made for Jessica from a vintage pair of mittens owned by my ex husband (Joe Fasanella). On the off chance he’d trust me with them again (these belonged to his father), I called him up and asked to borrow them. After extracting my promise that I wouldn’t take them apart -he knows me too well; things I really really like, I take apart- he sent them to me. Cool huh? Now you’ll see what I meant when I said these mittens produced for the Civil Conservation Corps during the Great Depression were totally unique. Below is your standard view, nothing untoward thus far.

Below I’m parting away the thumb from the left mitten. Do make note of that seam in the crook of the thumb; it’s an unusual jog.

Below is another view of it, off side.

And lastly, is rough sketch of an approximation of the pattern. The thumb has a true gusset. Some gussets aren’t really gussets being insets or oddly shaped insertions rather than actual additions of area. This one has the gusset built into the thumb piece. Obviously, this sketch is an estimation since party-pooper Joe Fasanella won’t let me take it apart, heh heh heh.

I’d say this version would be the more difficult style to sew. Let’s see if we have any takers on developing this one further. Speaking of takers, we’ve had three other entries. Carissa said:

First of all, we call these “muffins” around here. And “slippers” are also “flippers” in my household, but hey, we’re weird! In high Carissa fashion, I went ahead and developed a short term obsession over these muffins and I have really fallen in love with the results. The first thing I did, was tried to get into Jessica’s brain, however scary a place that may be, and I tried to solve the mystery of the flipped thumb.

I didn’t come up with the neatly laying gusseted thumb that a lot of people were thinking about. I was wondering up she wanted to improve the range of motion for the thumb and also had the top piece so much bigger so that the seams wouldn’t be directly on the sides of the muffins. I also noticed that the finger part was slightly bulbous for finger spreading room. –I really LOVE wearing muffins in the winter but I hate the limited range of motion that I feel with the thumb and the fingers. It’s like, my fingers and thumbs are either bound up and I’ve lost all association with the rest of the prehensile races, or I have floppy bags over my hands and can’t turn a door knob to save my life. So, my goal was, use this pattern as a spring board to a muffin with the seams on the inside of the hand, a good range of motion, room to spread the fingers, but maintain sleekness. I think I reached my goals! Yay! I’m so scared!! I can’t believe I’m letting you look at these, Kathleen!

I had some difficulty with these photos (please send yours as separate attachments) so blame me if these are too small. Two views from Carissa.

Then Christy Burton said:

I typically don’t consider myself an obtuse person, but I don’t get the mittens! I first sewed my inside and outside pieces together thinking that inside meant the palm and outside meant the back of the hand. (Gathered that from you saying to walk the two pieces together.) It worked okay but the thumb was twisted (my curves didn’t hit in the same place) and I thought I did something whacky. Then I gave up on sewing the two pieces together and made my own damn mitten with only one piece. When my boyfriend John got home, he said “where’s the inside? This pattern says inside and outside”. I NEVER thought that maybe inside meant… inside. Is he right or was I right to sew the two pieces together? Either way, I’m sticking to yoga pants.

Then Carol raises the bar and puts us all to shame with her very in depth mitten making experiment she posted in the forum. Here are some sample photos.

I’ll most likely post Carol’s entry in a post all its own since you have to be a member of the forum to see it (forum membership is now a premium only offered to financial supporters of Fashion-Incubator).

Now I have to trot off and get my stuff together for my trip to Austin. Eric and I are leaving tomorrow morning so I’ll most likely blog from there. Have a great weekend.

Get New Posts by Email


  1. Carol Kimball says:

    Aw, Christy, you have nothing to be ashamed of – you worked up a pattern and made a sample and were brave enough to submit them. If I could lay hands on some of my patterns done 20-25 years ago, you’d see that you’re ahead of where I was then. I have drifted into professional techniques because (as Kathleen keeps saying) they’re faster and more accurate. Walking patterns and building [Japanese term for idiot-proofing] into the marks means if you start to put something together wrong, you catch it before you’re in too deep. That makes this kind of goofing around fun!

    Recognizing where to go the next time(s) is what’s critical. Coming here is learning, and participating is learning squared. I was suprised (and pleased) at some of the stuff that turned up working through this.

    For the rest of you: the contest isn’t over yet. Look how many different successful approaches have come in. Give me the chance to learn more from you.

  2. Jess says:

    Kathleen, I’m wondering if you got my email with the entries for the logo contest? I think that something is wrong with my email and they aren’t being delivered.

  3. Christy B. says:

    Hi Carol, I’m mostly embarassed because I make patterns for a living!! It was fun to play with in my down time and my cats enjoyed attacking my sample. I’m excited to see what others come up with…

  4. Carissa says:

    Christy, I don’t know yet if I marked mine correctly or not either. I labored over Kathleen’s book and misc. pics. of patterns that she has on this blog to try to figure out how to mark mine- but I really have no clue seeing that I’m a non-pattern person and all. I’m trying to force myself to become somewhat a pattern person- it’s very difficult for me!
    Don’t look at mine and think I have my act together. The true test would be if someone who knows patterns could follow mine to make a mitten and it sew up easily. Mine could turn out to be a t-shirt in the end for all I know! lol Afterall- I couldn’t even e-mail my pictures right! (My brilliance is blinding, I know.)
    Oh well, at least Carol has her act together!

  5. Carol Kimball says:

    Carissa, if I were making up your pattern from only the photos given above*, I’d be matching up your single notches and pleating out or easing in the material between the doubles, to create more room over the top of the hand to allow quite a bit of movement – a creative solution to a sewn product that can need to join tricky tight curved pieces (like Mr. Fasanella’s).

    * i.e. good enough, though we all want to make it as easy as possible for Kathleen to include us.

    You and Christy made finished patterns and working prototypes. All Charlie has to date is one paper mitten stapled partly together across the top.

Leave a Reply

You have to agree to the comment policy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.